Post–World War II air-to-air combat losses

Air-to-air combat is the engagement of combat aircraft in warfare in which primarily fixed-wing aircraft attempt to destroy enemy aircraft using guns, rockets and missiles. The Korean War saw the greatest amount of air-to-air combat since World War II. During the war the United States claimed to have shot down around 700 fighters.[A 1][2] After the war the U.S. Air Force reviewed its figures in an investigation code-named Sabre Measure Charlie and downgraded the kill ratio of the North American F-86 Sabre against the Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-15 by half from 14:1 to 7:1.[2] One of the factors inflating US numbers was that most dogfights took place over enemy-controlled area. The only way to confirm kills was through gun camera photography. USAF pilots were credited with a kill if the gun camera showed their guns striking the enemy aircraft even if no one actually saw it go down.[3] However, Soviet Air Force kill claims were also highly exaggerated, based upon inherent flaws in their film grading procedures. For instance, the S-13 gun camera was not aligned with either the gunsight or either cannons' ballistics. It ran only while the firing buttons were depressed. Film graders commonly included unit commanders and political commisars who would confirm a "kill"—sometimes even if one had not been claimed by a pilot—when the camera's crosshairs touched the target for two movie frames. During the first 16 months of combat Soviet V-VS units claimed 218 F-86s destroyed when only 36 (35 to the two elite IADs and one to the 50th IAD) had been lost. This results in a 600 per cent inflation rate in victory credits over actual Sabres destroyed. However, these figures are complicated by the fact that the Americans routinely attributed combat losses to landing accidents and other causes.[4]

The last moments of a U.S. Air Force recon C-130 Hercules in gun camera of the Soviet MiG-17 (2 September 1958)
Gun camera sequence photo showing a North Vietnamese MiG-17-fighter being hit.
Gun camera sequence photos showing a North Vietnamese MiG-17 being hit and shot down by 20 mm shells from a U.S. Air Force F-105D Thunderchief during the Vietnam War (3 June 1967)

The Vietnam War saw a move away from cannon fire to air-to-air missiles.[5] Although US forces maintained air supremacy throughout the war, there were still occasional dogfights and US and North Vietnamese aces. The North Vietnamese side claimed the Vietnam People's Air Force had 17 aces throughout the war, including Nguyễn Văn Cốc, who is also the top ace of Vietnam War with 9 kills: seven acknowledged by the United States Air Force.

During the 1947 conflict over Jammu and Kashmir, the Indian Air Force did not engage the Pakistan Air Force in air-to-air combat; however, it did provide effective transport and close air support to the Indian Army troops.[6]

On 10 April 1959, an Indian English Electric Canberra was shot down while performing a Reconnaissance mission over Rawalpindi. The Canberra was shot down by a Pakistani F-86 Sabre flown by Flight Lieutenant M Younis of the No. 15 Squadron. The two crew members of the Canberra ejected and were later arrested by Pakistani authorities, this incident also marked the first aerial victory of the Pakistan Air Force.[7][8][9]

The Indo-Pakistani War of 1965 was the first time the Indian Air Force actively engaged an enemy air force.[10] By the time the conflict had ended, India had lost between 65 and 75 aircraft while Pakistan lost 20 aircraft.[11][12]

During the Indo-Pakistani war of 1971, the Indian Air Force lost 45 aircraft while the Pakistani Air Force lost 75.[13]

During the Iran–Iraq War of 1980–88, there were nearly 1,000 air-to-air engagements between Iran and Iraq, including the only known instances of helicopters dogfighting and shooting down other helicopters.[14] The Falklands War of 1982 witnessed air combat between Argentine and British military aircraft. The Falkland Islands' runways were short and thus unable to support fighter jets, forcing Argentina to launch fighters from the mainland, which had an adverse effect on their loiter time. The Argentine forces lost 23 aircraft in air-to-air combat, out of a total of 134 fixed wing aircraft and helicopters lost during the conflict. During the 1990–91 Persian Gulf War 33 of Iraqi Armed Forces' 750 fixed wing aircraft were claimed as downed (23 were confirmed), compared to 14 coalition aircraft claimed as downed (4 losses are confirmed, one F/A-18 Hornet and three UAVs[15]).[16][17]

Aircraft lost to air-to-air combat

edit
ConflictAir ForceAircraft lost to air-to-air combatReference
US incursions into Yugoslav airspace (1946) USAAF2[A 2][18]
Indonesian National Revolution Royal Indian Air Force2[19]
Arab–Israeli War (1948–1949)  Royal Air Force5[20]
 Israeli Air Force7 (Western claim); 0-1 (Israeli claim)[21][22][23][24]
Royal Egyptian Air Force15[21]
Syrian Air Force2[21]
Korean War (1950–1953)[A 3] PLAAF
North Korean Air Force
Soviet Air Defence Forces
335 (all causes USSR claim); 399(PLAAF claim) & 270 NKAF (US claim)[25][26][27]
US Aircraft757 (US Air Force only, 139 in air-to-air combat, 305 "unknown", 472 "other losses"), 1,200 (USSR claimed kills), 85 (PRC claimed kills)[28][29]
UN Coalition Aircraft197 (Soviet claim), 139 (UN claim)[A 4][30]
South Korean Air Force135
US incursions into Soviet airspace (1950–1970) US Aircraft16[A 5]
Soviet Air Defence Forces3[A 6]
Catalina affair Swedish Air Force2
Avro Lincoln shoot down incident  Royal Air Force1[31]
Air battle over Merklín USAFE1[A 7][19]
Bombing of Plaza de Mayo (1955) Argentine Naval Aviation1[32]
Suez Crisis (1956) Egypt Air Force7–9[33]
 Israeli Air Force1[34]
 Royal Air Force1[A 8][35]
Secret electronic surveillance missions US Navy2[36]
Permesta Rebellion CIA/AUREV1[37]
Second Taiwan Strait Crisis[A 9] PLAAF32 (ROC claim); 5 (PRC claim)[38]
ROCAF14 (PRC claim); 3 (ROC claim)[38]
1959 Canberra shootdown

[A 10]

 Pakistan Air Force0[39][40]
 Indian Air Force1[39]
Vietnam War (1959–1975)[A 11] Vietnam People's Air Force131 (North Vietnam claim); 195 (US claim)[41][42]
US Aircraft128 (US Claim), 266 (North Vietnam claim)[43][44][45][46]
Republic of Vietnam Air Force72[42]
Taiwanese incursion into Burma airspace Republic of China Air Force1[18]
First Iraqi–Kurdish War Iraqi Air Force2[47]
Dutch–Indonesian Conflict  Indonesian Air Force1[19]
Project Dark Gene (1960–79) Soviet Air Force1[48][49]
Imperial Iranian Air Force6[48][50][51][52]
Bay of Pigs Invasion Brigade 250610 (Confirmed)[53]
Six-Day War (1967)  Israeli Air Force Israeli Air Force12 (Israeli claim); 20 (ACIG claim)[22][23][54][24]
Egypt Air Force
Syrian Air Force
 Royal Jordanian Air Force
64–72[A 12][55][56]
Indo-Pakistani Air War of 1965  Indian Air Force60-75[57]
Pakistan Air Force20[12][57]
War of Attrition (1967-1970)  Egyptian Air Force60 (Egyptian claim);113 (Israeli claim)[55]
 Israeli Air Force4 (Israeli claim)[24]
Football War[A 13] Air Force of El Salvador3[58]
Indo-Pakistan War of 1971  Indian Air Force45[59][60]
Pakistan Air Force75[60]
Turkish invasion of Cyprus Turkish Air Force1 (Greek claim)[61]
Yom Kippur War (1973)  Israeli Air Force5 (Israeli claim)[24]
 Egyptian Air Force
Syrian Air Force
277 (Israeli claim)[24]
Libyan–Egyptian War (1977) Libyan Air Force4–5[62]
Egypt Air Force1[62]
Iranian and Soviet airspace incursions (1970s) Imperial Iranian Army Aviation + IIAF2[A 14] + 3[52][63][64]
Soviet Air Force1[65]
Soviet–Afghan War Afghan National Army Air Corps8[66]
Pakistan Air Force1[66]
Islamic Republic of Iran Army Aviation2[A 15][67]
Mojahedin4[68]
Nicaraguan Revolution Nicaraguan Air Force2[69]
Iran–Iraq War (1980–1988) Iraqi Aircraft234 (confirmed)[70][71]
Iranian Aircraft73 (confirmed)[72]
Soviet Air Force3 (Iranian claim); 0 (Soviet claim)[73][74]
Syrian Air Force3[75]
Algerian Government Aircraft1[75]
Turkish Air Force1[76]
South African Border War South African Air Force1[77]
National Air Force of Angola2[77]
US Freedom of Navigation operations near Libya (1980–1989) Libyan Air Force4[78]
Salvadoran Civil War FMLN supply aircraft1[79]
Falklands War Argentine Naval Aviation/Argentine Air Force23[80]
Army Air Corps1[81]
1982 Lebanon War Syrian Air Force82–86 (Israeli claim)[82][83][84]
Israeli Air Force1 (Israeli claim); 42 (Syrian claim); 3 (ACIG claim)[85][86][87][24]
Sri Lankan Civil War (1983–2009) Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam1[88]
Tanker War (1984–1988) Islamic Republic of Iran Air Force1 (Iranian claim) 2 (Saudi claim)[89][90]
Persian Gulf War (1990–1991) United States Navy4 (US claim);[91][15] 12 (Iraqi claim)[16][17]
Royal Air Force1 (Iraqi claim)[92]
Italian Air Force1 (Iraqi claim)[92]
Royal Saudi Air Force1 (Iraqi claim)[93]
Iraqi Air Force23 (Iraqi claim); 44 (Coalition claim)[16][17]
Iraqi no-fly zones enforcement US Aircraft3[A 16][94]
Iraqi Air Force5
Croatian War of Independence (1991–1995) Italian Army1[A 17][95]
1992 Venezuelan coup d'état attempts Bolivarianos3[96]
Operation Deny Flight Republika Srpska Air Force5[97]
Cenepa War (1995) Ecuadorian Air Force1 (confirmed), 2 (Ecuadorian claim)[98]
Aegean dispute (1996) Turkish Air Force1[99][100]
Eritrean–Ethiopian War (1998–2000) Eritrean Air Force2–6[101]
Ethiopian Air ForceUp to 7[102][103]
Operation Allied Force Yugoslav Air Force5 + 1 heavily damaged, later destroyed on the ground[104]
NATO Air Force1 + 1 Tomahawk[105][106]
Atlantique incident Pakistan Navy1[107]
2001–02 India–Pakistan standoff  Indian Air Force Indian Air Force1 [A 18][108][109]
Iran–Israel proxy conflict  Hezbollah UAVs2[110][111]
2008 Georgian spy plane shootdowns Georgian Air Force1[112][113]
Iraq War (2003–2011) Islamic Republic of Iran Air Force1[A 19][114]
War in Afghanistan (2001–2021) United States Air Force1[A 20][115]
Syrian Civil War Syrian Air Force7[116][117][118][119][120][121][122]
Russian Air Force2[123][124]
"Pro-Syria regime" forces3[A 21][125][126][127][128]
Iran–Israel proxy conflict  Iran1[129]
War in Donbass Ukrainian Air Force1 (Ukrainian claim)[130]
Second Libyan Civil War Turkish Air Force1[131]
Second Yemeni Civil War Houthis4 (Arab Coalition claim)[132][133]
2016 Turkish coup d'état attempt Peace at Home Council2[134]
Balochistan Conflict Iran1[135][136][137]
2019 India–Pakistan standoff  Indian Air Force1 (1 Mig-21 confirmed), 1 (1 Su-30MKI claimed by Pakistan)[138]
Pakistani Air Force1 (F-16 claimed by India)[139][140][141]
2020 Nagorno-Karabakh War Armenian Air Force1 (Armenian claim)[142]
2021 Israel-Palestine conflict Hamas1[143]
2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine Ukrainian Air Force11 (as of 4 August 2023)[144]
Ukrainian Naval Aviation1[145][146]
United States Air Force1 (MQ-9 Reaper UAV)[147]

See also

edit

Footnotes

edit

References

edit

Notes

edit

Bibliography

edit
edit